United breaks guitars case analysis executive summary united breaks guitars is a song made by dave carroll in which it describes his experience on the flight by united airlines and the following reaction from united. He shows how to handle a bad situation in a nonconfrontational manner. Traveling on united airlines from halifax, nova scotia, to omaha, nebraska, carroll changed planes in chicago. Air guitars and other highfluting instruments dont trust an airline with your instrument united airlines apparently tries to wrestle a 17thcentury violin from a musician. Now, hes come out with a book united breaks guitars. Songwriter dave carroll turned the destruction of his taylor by united airlines into notoriety with his song united breaks guitars, with more than 17 million youtube views, and a spinoff book about his resulting socialmedia odyssey.
The power of one voice in the age of social media on facebook. His video, united breaks guitars, got a million views in just four days and prompted the airline to offer him compensation. In june 20, the nbc tv used the videos as part of a panel discussion on how to properly complain and get what you want. Not sure i want to see united breaks heads, though perhaps the clash or the sex pistols could do the video. Singer gets his revenge on united airlines and soars to. Roasted in the social media case study united breaks. The book goes indepth about how an accidental spokesperson for an airline brand can mean trouble in the long term and how to handle such crises. United breaks guitars case study 5th july, 2014 presented by ronak mehta 2. United breaks guitars the book by dave carroll is just as engaging as his video. The power of one voice in the age of social media is his firstperson tale of his experience with united airlines handling of his taylor guitar and the ensuing circus that was his journey through their massive customer service system. United breaks guitars, and we support dave carroll and the. United breaks guitars song 3 united we stand on the. Screenshot from the united breaks guitars music video. Setting the stage provides the background of his musical career, the guitar breaking incident and his ongoing but fruitless conversations with united airlines.
Musician dave carroll flying on united saw his guitar get tossed around on the ramp. Carroll posted the incredibly creative and hilarious. United breaks guitars singer reprises youtube airline lament. Social media crisis communications case study united. Jul 11, 2009 united breaks guitars july 11, 2009 7. United breaks guitars pdf summary dave carroll 12min blog. The crippling of the canadian musicians beloved taylor guitar at the hands of united airlines baggage handlers became the stuff of folklore.
As viral videos spread and what can companies do with. Air guitars and other highfluting instruments dont. Upon its release on the internet, it draws many peoples attention and immediately becomes a hit on the youtube. When the airplane arrived in nebraska, carroll discovered that. United breaks guitars is a protest song by canadian musician dave carroll and his band, sons of maxwell. Dave breaks the book united breaks guitars into four sections.
United breaks guitars singer dave carroll reprises youtube. Blogs in the case of united breaks guitars, when the video was placed on youtube it struck a. I think its ultimately good for both united and the airline industry to get this kind of feedback. United breaks guitars is a trio of protest songs by canadian musician dave carroll and his. Highvalue, fragile or perishable items can also include. United breaks guitars has become a youtube sensation and provided dave carroll with the biggest hit of his career. I got here by googling crisis management and united breaks guitars. United breaks guitars guy says airline shows lack of. Jul 06, 2009 in the spring of 2008, sons of maxwell were traveling to nebraska for a oneweek tour and my taylor guitar was witnessed being thrown by united airlines baggage handlers in chicago. He used social media to tell the story you wont believe how i got a copy of this book. The united breaks guitars video is an excellent example of how grassroots campaigns can go viral across a spectrum of media, and how different media can influence one another. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Dave carrol, a musician traveled in united airlines and finds his guitar being broke due to poor cargo handling. United breaks guitars has become a textbook example of the new relationship between companies and their customers, and has demonstrated the power of one voice in the age of social media.
Taylor guitars sent the musician two new custom guitars in appreciation for the product recognition from the video that has led to. The incident time march 2008 who dave carroll, a musician from halifax, ns and his band, the sons of maxwell, traveled from halifax to nebraska via ohare airport in chicago. United airlines in a pr nightmare after united breaks. On march 31, 2008 sons of maxwell began our weeklongtour of nebraska by flying united airlines from halifax to omaha, by way of chicago. Get your own copy of united breaks guitars song 3 on itunes or visit the store to buy the mp3. The guitar was severely mangled when he picked it up, yet united airlines refused to pick up the tab. By far, the greatest story of one persons socialmedia victory over bigairline lies and mistreatment. United aggressively responds to united breaks guitars. Broken guitar has united playing the blues to the tune of. I have been a fan of daves music and enjoy his live perfromances.
The united breaks guitars issue dominated the news for united airlines with 42% of coverage. Blogs in the case of united breaks guitars, when the video was placed on youtube it struck a chord with key influencers on the web. The power of one voice in the age of social media, which has just been published. May 15, 20 following his 2009 youtube music video release called united breaks guitars, about his poor customer service experience with united airlines, daves career blossomed and he is now a highlysoughtafter performer, content creator, author, keynote speaker, and consumer advocate. Now that the united breaks guitars meme has blown up across the internet, dave carroll has posted a video response addressing the airlines belated offer to repay him. I would never fly united unless it was literally the only airline going to the city i needed to be in, and there was no way to fly to a different city in the region and rent a car and drive where i had to go, because of this song. It has become a benchmark in the customerservice and music industries, as well as branding and socialmedia circles. Jul 10, 2009 a musician whose guitar was damaged by united airlines exacted his revenge by writing a song that has become a youtube video sensation. United airlines had broken daves guitar in checked luggage. United breaks guitars summary by dave carroll overdrive.
In 2008, carroll, a canadian singersongwriter, jetted to nebraska for a gig via a united airlines flight from halifax, nova scotia, with a layover. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading united breaks guitars. Daves story of how united airlines broke his taylor guitar and the roadblocks that he encountered in having the company offer restitution and an apology resonates with many frustrated consumers. United breaks guitars guy says airline shows lack of compassion in. Aug 19, 2009 united breaks guitars song 2 is a lament to irlweg about what could have been, had she not been forced to adhere to united s policies. The case tells about the events that followed slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising.
Musician dave carroll said his guitar was broken while in united airlines custody. It also includes a download link for six of his songs, including all three parts of the book title song. Service marketing presentation untied breaks guitars free download as powerpoint presentation. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. A harvard business school case studies detailing dave carrolls use of youtube to pressure united airlines to making right a situation in which his guitar had been damaged at chicagos ohare airport. The pie chart shows the breakdown of different issues in online news for united airlines in july 2010. The power of one voice in the age of social media, published by hay house publishing. Following his 2009 youtube music video release called united breaks guitars, about his poor customer service experience with united airlines, daves career blossomed and he is now a highlysoughtafter performer, content creator, author, keynote speaker, and consumer advocate. Since united breaks guitars emerged, nothing is the samefor consumers, for musicians, or for business. United breaks guitars kindle edition by carroll, dave. Irlweg, that i would write and produce three songs about my experience with united airlines and make videos for each to be viewed online by anyone in the world, carroll said on his website. United breaks guitars guy says airline shows lack of compassion in wake of latest pr disaster back in 2008, united airlines broke dave carrolls guitar and refused to pay for it.
Oh my god, theyre throwing guitars out there in the spring of 2008, musician dave carroll embarked on a plane trip that changed his life and led him to write a fresh chapter in the history of customer relations. United breaks guitars harvard business school working. Dave carroll is a singersongwriter and social media. United breaks guitars singer reprises youtube airline lament after 5m youtube hits for his first song about broken guitar, country and western. United aggressively responds to united breaks guitars part 2. I flew united airlines on my way to nebraska the plane departed, halifax, connecting in ch.
The power of one voice in the age of social media reprint by carroll, dave isbn. Items checked in sacks or paper and plastic bags that arent durable, dont close securely or dont provide enough protection items checked in cardboard boxes, including boxes we provide, except for items that otherwise would be suitable for transportation without the cardboard box. He found it was broken, and after months of trying to solve the problem, he gave up and wrote a song. Harvard business school publishing corporation harvard business school. It chronicles a reallife experience of how his guitar was broken during a trip on united airlines in 2008, and the reaction from the airline. Sons of maxwell is a canadian music duo who perform both traditional celtic folk music and original compositions with a popfolk sound. Jun 18, 2014 all that said, united airlines is probably not most musicians first choice when it comes to flying with their musical instrument, ever since dave carroll endured a broken taylor guitar and frustration getting compensated, leading to his hit song united breaks guitars. United breaks guitars united airlines stocks world.
Be the first to ask a question about united breaks guitars. Get your own copy of united breaks guitars on itunes or visit the store to buy. In may, 2012 dave carroll wrote a book about his customer experience called, united breaks guitars. In january 2012, united breaks guitars was featured in the cnbc documentary customer disservice. The united breaks guitars cottage industry brings us a dave carroll book about dealing.
United breaks guitar a case study on online reputation. Due to its large file size, this book may take longer to download. It has become a benchmark in the customerservice and. How united breaks guitars kept me glued to my chair. United sees no need to make anything right, oh ms irlweg, we. United airlines has subsequently contacted the musician and offered to pay him to take down the video. In the spring of 2008, sons of maxwell were traveling to nebraska for a oneweek tour and my taylor guitar was witnessed being thrown by united airlines baggage handlers in chicago.
Song over guitar broken by airline a youtube hit globe. United breaks guitars documents the incredible viral power of social media, analyzing the reach and impact of a clever customer complaint music video produced by canadian musician dave carroll when his attempts to recoup the value of his guitar broken in. The power of one voice in the age of social media by dave carroll isbn. Dave carroll responds to customer service incident on. Taylor guitars sent the musician two new custom guitars in appreciation for the product recognition from the video that has led to a sharp increase in orders.
Back in 2008, united airlines broke dave carrolls guitar and refused to pay. It chronicles a reallife experience of how his guitar was broken during a trip on united airlines in 2008, and the subsequent reaction from the airline. United breaks guitars and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. United breaks guitars dave carroll an award winning. When the airlines smashed a songwriters guitar and refused to reimburse him, he got even by going viral. But despite struggling with the airline for months, carroll turned. Dave carroll personal appearances offering an extraordinary experience and maybe a custom song and video. The primary influencers at the beginning of the campaign seem to have been bloggers twitter influencelarge number of references linking to youtube. Dave carrolls book united breaks guitars is both an entertaining account of his misadventures with united airlines and a guidelineinspiration for consumer activism in the new age of social media. I was just curious about how united might have handledbe handling this situation. In may 2012, carroll published a book, united breaks guitars. Dave carroll united breaks guitars lyrics musixmatch. I promised the last person from united airlines to finally say no to compensation, ms. Singer gets his revenge on united airlines and soars to fame.
Jul 23, 2009 singer gets his revenge on united airlines and soars to fame. The duo consists of brothers don carroll and dave carroll, originally from timmins, ontario, residing in halifax, nova scotia since 1994. Jun 20, 2017 case analysis the united breaks guitars video is an excellent example of how grassroots campaigns can go viral across a spectrum of media, and how different media can influence one another. The graph shows different media and how they potentially influenced one another and drove traffic to the youtube video. United breaks guitars surpasses 3 million views in 10 days. The power of one voice in the age of social media, detailing his experiences. Aug 24, 2009 i know united said it had learned from its mistakes in dealing with the nowfamous song united breaks guitars, but i didnt know whether to believe it or not. United breaks guitars case solution and analysis, hbr case. If youre seeing this message, that means javascript has been disabled on your browser, please enable js to make this app work. The full story on march 31, 2008 sons of maxwell began our weeklongtour of nebraska by flying united airlines from halifax to omaha, by way of chicago.
The story of dave carrolls broken guitar is the profoundly moving account of how one man took on an implacable system and won. United breaks guitars pdf summary in the spring of 2008, dave carroll embarked on a trip from his hometown halifax, nova scotia to omaha, nebraska, where he was supposed to have a concert with his band, sons of maxwell. United breaks guitars is a great song and was the perfect comeback. The power of social media became amusingly apparent in 2009, when united airlines refused to compensate canadian singer and composer dave carroll for a guitar that the airlines baggage handlers had broken. United breaks guitars case solution,united breaks guitars case analysis, united breaks guitars case study solution, when social media spread complaints about poor customer service, an international media event should. Songwriter dave carroll wasnt the first person abused by an airlines. Whether you are a guitarist, a baggage handler, or a boardroom executive, this book will entertain you and remind you that we are all connected, that each of us matters, and that we all have a voice worth hearing. The united breaks guitars book is the story of one mans broken taylor guitar, a casualty of united airlines. The united breaks guitars cottage industry brings us a dave carroll book about dealing with customer service. Songwriter dave carroll wasnt the first person abused by an airlines customer. This is the story of a passenger whose guitar got broken when he flew united, and their are some real lessons about customer service in the plight of dave carroll, and taylor guitars superb response. This video is a response by sons of maxwell singer dave carroll to some incredibly poor customer service by united airlines. We already know that united breaks guitars has a hit a nerve with the web world, but visible measures has just released their findings and as we expected, united has a real nightmare on their.
United breaks guitars is a trio of protest songs by canadian musician dave carroll and his band, sons of maxwell. United breaks guitars dave carroll an award winning singer. United breaks guitars, which he performed with his halifaxbased band sons of maxwell, filmed, and put on youtube. Aug 08, 2018 a volunteer firefighter in his free time, dave carroll has so far written only one book. United breaks guitars harvard business school working knowledge.
The exposure we gained from the message, well placed, was essentially free and had a very positive. Next time an airline loses or breaks your luggage, try shaming them with a song and a video. Service marketing presentation untied breaks guitars. Dave carrolls united breaks guitars is a brilliant use of social media, said taylor. United breaks guitars pdf summary recounts the story of how the ubg trio of. Social media crisis communications case study united airlines breaks guitars posted on july 12, 2009 by howard greenstein markets are conversations. Case study united breaks guitars musician dave carroll turned an unfortunate experience into a catchy, funny song published on youtube which received millions of views, was reproduced thousands of times on the web, and was covered by major network media. On the first leg of the flight youre seated at the rear of the aircraft. A case study coauthored by professor john deighton and research associate leora kornfeld offers an object lesson in the dangers social media can bring for big, recognizable companies and their brands. Takelessons would like to share the youtube video of united breaks guitars, musician dave carrolls musical assertion that a united airlines baggage handler damaged his taylor guitar tossing it around at chicago ohare in his song, carroll says another passenger saw carrolls guitar being tossed by a united employee. I thoroughly enjoyed dave carrolls first book, united breaks guitars. Get the key points from this book in less than 10 minutes. I flew united airlines on my way to nebraska the plane departed, halifax, connecting in chicagos. A man who became a youtube sensation after he wrote a song about united airlines breaking his guitar in 2009 is speaking out after the.
1450 563 1272 636 406 404 42 680 926 343 36 1525 291 283 1289 337 493 1066 404 655 942 184 107 696 726 396 299 1369 255 734 1339 598 1281 607 789 1399 690 701